Introduction
The Philippine legal system, rooted in civil law traditions, has specific provisions concerning inheritance and the protection of heirs. One significant aspect of succession law is the concept of compulsory heirs—those who cannot be deprived of their inheritance without just cause. However, the law provides instances when even these heirs may be disinherited under specific circumstances. This article explores the legal framework governing the disinheritance of compulsory heirs in the Philippines, the valid grounds for disinheritance, and the procedural requirements for such disinheritance to be valid.
Compulsory Heirs: A Brief Overview
Under the Civil Code of the Philippines, compulsory heirs are individuals who, by law, are entitled to receive a portion of the deceased's estate, even against the will of the decedent. These heirs include:
1. Legitimate children and descendants.
2. Legitimate parents and ascendants.
3. The surviving spouse.
4. Illegitimate children (who are entitled to a smaller share than legitimate ones).
The portion of the estate reserved for these heirs is called the legitime, and it cannot be freely disposed of by the testator through a will. However, the law permits disinheritance of compulsory heirs, subject to strict requirements.
Legal Basis for Disinheritance
The disinheritance of compulsory heirs in the Philippines is governed by Articles 915 to 922 of the Civil Code. It is important to note that disinheritance must be expressed in a valid will and can only be done for legally prescribed causes. If disinheritance is done outside of these prescribed grounds or if procedural requirements are not followed, the act is void.
Grounds for Disinheritance
Articles 919 to 921 of the Civil Code provide exhaustive grounds for disinheriting each category of compulsory heir. These causes must exist at the time the will is made, and they must be explicitly stated in the will.
1. For Children and Descendants (Art. 919):
- Conviction of a crime involving physical harm or an attempt against the life of the testator, their spouse, or ascendants/descendants.
- Accusation against the testator of a crime punishable by imprisonment of six years or more, if the accusation is found to be false.
- Use of violence or coercion to compel the testator to change their will.
- Refusal to support the testator when legally required.
- Maltreatment or serious insult to the testator.
2. For Parents and Ascendants (Art. 920):
- Abandonment of the children or descendants by their parents.
- Conviction of an offense punishable by a long-term prison sentence.
- Accusation against a child or descendant of a crime punishable by imprisonment of six years or more, knowing the accusation to be false.
- Seduction, corruption, or maltreatment of the testator's child.
- Serious insult by deed or words against the testator.
3. For the Surviving Spouse (Art. 921):
- Adultery or concubinage.
- Conviction of an offense punishable by long-term imprisonment.
- Attempt against the life of the testator, their children, or ascendants.
- Serious insults or maltreatment towards the testator.
Procedural Requirements for Valid Disinheritance
For disinheritance to be legally valid, several procedural requirements must be met:
1. Written in a Will: Disinheritance must be explicitly stated in the testator's last will and testament. A general or vague statement is insufficient.
2. Grounds Must Be Stated: The will must specifically mention the grounds for disinheritance as provided by law. Failing to indicate a legally prescribed cause voids the disinheritance.
3. Grounds Must Be Proven: In cases where the disinherited heir contests the disinheritance, the testator's estate or the other heirs must prove the existence of the ground(s) for disinheritance. If no sufficient proof is provided, the disinheritance may be invalidated by the courts.
4. Subsequent Forgiveness Nullifies Disinheritance: If the testator pardons or reconciles with the disinherited heir after committing the act that justified disinheritance, the disinheritance becomes void. Such forgiveness may be either express or implied by the testator’s actions.
Effects of Disinheritance
When a compulsory heir is validly disinherited, they lose their right to the legitime. However, their descendants (if any) will still inherit in their place. This principle ensures that the disinheritance does not unfairly prejudice future generations.
For example, if a child is disinherited by the parent, the grandchildren can still inherit their parent's share by virtue of representation.
Challenging Disinheritance
Disinheritance can be contested in court, particularly if the disinherited party believes that the grounds cited are false or unjustified. Heirs may also challenge the validity of the will if they believe it was executed under duress, mistake, or undue influence.
If the court finds the disinheritance invalid, the heir will be reinstated to their rightful share of the estate, including the legitime.
Conclusion
Disinheritance of compulsory heirs in the Philippines is a legally complex process. While the law provides certain grounds for disinheriting an heir, these must be strictly followed to ensure the disinheritance is valid. The protection of compulsory heirs is a fundamental aspect of Philippine succession law, ensuring that heirs receive their rightful share of the estate unless a justifiable cause for disinheritance exists. For anyone considering disinheritance, it is essential to consult legal professionals to ensure compliance with the law and to protect the validity of the will.
Source: Ziggurat Real Estate
Comments