Sale of Mortgaged Property to Creditor Per Se Is Not Prohibited

When dealing with mortgaged properties, many people assume that selling such assets to the creditor is legally prohibited. However, this is not necessarily the case. Under the right legal framework, the sale of a mortgaged property to the creditor is allowed, provided that it does not violate laws on foreclosure, dation in payment, or the prohibition against pactum commissorium.

How Mortgages Can Be Paid

A mortgage is a security interest granted over a property to secure the performance of an obligation, typically the repayment of a loan. The debtor can satisfy the mortgage in several ways:

1. Full Payment of the Loan – The most straightforward way to release the mortgage is by repaying the debt in full. Once the debt is fully paid, the creditor must execute a release of mortgage, which should then be registered with the relevant land registry.

2. Foreclosure Sale – If the debtor fails to pay, the creditor may initiate a foreclosure process to sell the property, either through a judicial or extrajudicial foreclosure proceeding. The proceeds from the sale are then used to settle the outstanding debt.

3. Dation in Payment (Dacion en Pago) – Instead of paying in cash, the debtor may transfer ownership of the mortgaged property to the creditor in satisfaction of the debt. This is a voluntary arrangement between both parties and is valid as long as it does not constitute a disguised pactum commissorium.

4. 
   

Relationship Between Dation in Payment and Pactum Commissorium

Dation in Payment (Dacion en Pago)

Dation in payment occurs when the debtor transfers ownership of the mortgaged property to the creditor in exchange for the extinguishment of the debt. This is a negotiated and consensual agreement between both parties. The key difference between dation in payment and a foreclosure sale is that in dation, the debtor willingly conveys ownership as an alternative means of settling the obligation.

For the dation to be valid, it must be agreed upon by both parties and must not be forced upon the debtor. It is a lawful and commonly used method of settling obligations when cash payment is not feasible.

Pactum Commissorium: The Prohibited Clause

Pactum commissorium, on the other hand, is an illegal provision in a mortgage or pledge that allows the creditor to automatically appropriate the mortgaged property in case of non-payment. This is prohibited because it is considered oppressive and inequitable to the debtor, as it bypasses the due process of foreclosure or voluntary dation.

For a transaction to be considered a prohibited pactum commissorium, two elements must be present:

1. A security arrangement (such as a mortgage or pledge).

2. An automatic transfer clause in favor of the creditor upon default.

Unlike dation in payment, which is voluntarily agreed upon after default, pactum commissorium is a pre-arranged forfeiture mechanism that is deemed invalid under the law.

Conclusion

The sale of a mortgaged property to the creditor is not inherently prohibited. It can be done through legitimate means, such as dation in payment or foreclosure. However, what is illegal is the automatic appropriation of the property by the creditor without due process, as seen in pactum commissorium. Understanding these legal concepts helps ensure that mortgage transactions remain fair and within the bounds of the law.

Source: Ziggurat Real Estate